American Idol Review – 10 Guys Battle It Out!

Posted on February 27, 2007 
Filed Under Music, Reality TV

Tonight the 10 remaining guys took the stage for your affections. The night began with Ryan Secrest congratulating former Idol and newly Oscar winner, Jennifer Hudson. After last week’s poor performances from the guys and a much superior one from the ladies, the guys knew they had to step it up tonight. We soon learn that its dedication week, where the contestant will dedicate their song selection and performance to a place, person or thing. 

Phil Stacey started the night with a strong performance of ‘Missing You’, dedicated to Navy Bound Southeast. Both Randy and Paula enjoyed his performance and gave him great reviews. However Simon disagrees and says. “I think you have a completely unoriginal voice.” 

My Thoughts: I agree with all the judges. He is a very good singer, an average performer and have an unoriginal voice. Overall, I feel that he will stick around, especially after his short marketing clip. His chance of making it to the finals is great considering he is competing against a weak field of guys. 

Jarred Cotter sang a Marvin Gaye classis ‘Let’s Get It On’, dedicated to his parents. Both Randy and Paula commented on his physical features rather than his vocal talents. After a comedy moment from the judges, Simon said what Randy and Paula couldn’t say, it his own analogy of course “It did remind me though of the Love Boat.  I’m kind of imagining if they had a cabaret singer on the Love Boat, I think we would have seen something similar to that, because it was a bit corny in parts.” 

My Thoughts: The performance was alright, he defiantly has stage presence. However he needs to work on his vocals and chose songs that really bring it out. Although it was a weak performance, I still think he will make it to the next round. If not than it’s a toss up between him and Brandon.   

A.J. Tabaldo came out with a little more personality and talent. He sang ‘Feeling Good’ dedicated to his mother and father. Randy commented on how much better it was compared to last week. Paula loves the way he is challenging himself in different areas and surprisingly Simon says “I have to say that was actually nearly very good.”  

My Thoughts: I have to give this kid props. I honestly felt that he did an amazing job. He has such a great voice and range and the ability to perform on stage. It’s great to see Asian-Americans on Idol who actually have talent, unlike former idol Jasmine Trias and Camille Velasco. A.J is actually really good and I believe he will be a factor in the Top 12.   

Sanjaya Malakar knew he had to come out with guns blazing in order to stay for another week. He came out whispering to the song ‘Steeping Out’ dedicated to his grandfather. His performance was weak according to Randy. Simon said it best “It was like some ghastly lunch, where after lunch your parents have asked the children to dress up and sing.” 

My Thoughts: Weak! I think his young age and lack of experience is really hurting him.  We still have not heard his vocal potential. Obviously the judges put him through for a reason and the way America voted last week, he must have some talent. Right? 

Chris Sligh, the marketing consultant with big hair sang ‘Trouble’ dedicating it to his wife who is in the audience. His performance was good enough to receive thumbs up from all judges. Simon says “Chris, the reason we put you through to this round is actually we thought you were a very good singer, and tonight you were a very good singer.”  

My Thoughts: I agree that he is a great singer with a big voice. However he is another one of those singers that I have to close my eyes to really appreciate his voice. He will be sticking around for another week or so. I’m sure by the time the top 12 are revealed, America will be familiar with his Jack Osborne look that his chances of making it to the big stage are better. 

Nicholas Pedro sang ‘You Give Me Fever’ dedicating it to his girlfriend. His performance was definitely a step up to his last. Randy and Paula thought it was good and so did Simon who added that he needed more charisma. 

My Thoughts: I honestly thought it was just ok. I’m not a fan of his voice. I find it too smoky and quiet, however with that said he will probably stick around at least for another week, with the ladies votes. 

Blake Lewis brought his beat-boxing back with a performance of ‘Virtual Insanity’ dedicating it to his parents. He receive great reviews from Randy and Paula on his original performance, however Simon disagrees and calls him a copy cat. 

My Thoughts: Like Richardson, he is not the strongest singer, however he does have a unique quality about him and he is also a great on-stage performer. He will stick around and probably will make it to the Big stage. 

Up next was Brandon Rogers, the former background singer sang ‘Time After Time’ dedicated to his grandmother, his heartfelt performance was boring for Randy and Simon says “You have got to come out here Brandon when you’re as talented as you are and do what four or five of these girls did last week and make a wow impact.”  

My Thoughts: I agree that he has great talent and although he tried to put his own flare to the song, I found it to be weak, uninspiring and it did nothing to show off his great voice. After tonight’s performance he might find himself saying goodbye on Thursday.

Chris Richardson sang ‘Geek The Pink’ an upbeat song dedicated to his grandmother. His performance again was far superior to the rest of the guys. He truly has a natural talent to perform on stage. Randy and Paula loved it, Simons says “For me, best tonight by a mile.” 

My Thoughts: I said it before and I’ll say it again, this guy has talent. He is not the strongest vocalist from the group however he has a sound that is hot today. Although he has been compared to Justin Timberlake, I think after tonight he has created his own identity. He is definitely the front runner for the guys. 

To close the night was Sundance Head. His performance to ‘Mustang Sally’ dedicated to his son came back much stronger than last week. The judges agreed and welcome him back. 

My Thoughts: I agree that it was better than last week, however similar to Chris Sligh I have to close my eyes when he performs. He does have a big voice, but nothing special about it.   

Tonight’s performance form the guys was definitely a step up from last week.  It’s hard to say which two guys will be leaving this week, as they have all improved. Although it’s a singing competition, it’s very similar to high school, looks and popularity ratings matter. Here are my predictions. 

Safe Idols: Phil Stacey, Jarred Cotter, A.J. Tabaldo, Chris Sligh, Nick Pedro, Blake Lewis and Chris Richardson. 

Troubled Idols: Sanjaya Malakar for sure and I think it’s a toss up between Brandon Rogers and Sundance Head.

Comments

Leave a Reply




About

Peogles speaks everything from humor, people, business, technology, sports, entertainment, life and everything else in between.

Admin

Credits

Vertigo Blue Theme by Brian Gardner
Powered by WordPress

Advertising